Skip to main content

Clinic Money and Tax

Presumptive Tax (44ADA) vs Full Books: Which Is Better for You

Should a doctor use presumptive tax (old 44ADA, now section 58) or keep full books? Limits, the 50% rule, when books win, and a worked example for 2026-27.

Bractis clinic guides · Updated · 5 min read

Short answer

Under presumptive taxation for professionals, formerly section 44ADA and now section 58 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, a doctor with gross receipts up to ₹50 lakh, or ₹75 lakh if cash receipts are within 5 percent, can declare 50 percent of receipts as income without detailed books. It suits doctors whose real expenses are below half their receipts. Keeping full books is better when your genuine expenses, such as rent, salaries, equipment and depreciation, are more than half your receipts, or when receipts exceed the limit.

The choice every private doctor faces

Every year a doctor in private practice must decide how to work out taxable income. One way is to keep full books of account, record every expense and pay tax on the actual profit. The other is the presumptive scheme for professionals, long known as section 44ADA and now section 58 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, which treats half of your gross receipts as income and spares you most of the paperwork.

Neither is always better. The right choice depends on how much you earn, how much you spend to earn it and how you are paid.

This guide is general information based on the law as it stood in November 2026, not tax advice. The Income-tax Act, 2025 replaced the 1961 Act from 1 April 2026 and renumbered many sections; older section numbers are given in brackets because most doctors and CAs still use them. Check your own case with a chartered accountant.

How the presumptive scheme works

On a narrow screen, scroll the table sideways to see every column.

PointRule for tax year 2026-27
Who can use itResident individuals and partnership firms (not LLPs) in specified professions, which include medicine
Receipts limitUp to ₹50 lakh; up to ₹75 lakh if cash receipts are no more than 5 percent of total receipts
Income declaredAt least 50 percent of gross receipts
ExpensesTreated as already allowed within the other 50 percent; you do not claim them separately
BooksDetailed books are generally not required while you declare at least 50 percent
Advance taxCan be paid in one instalment by 15 March
Declaring less than 50 percentAllowed only with books, and an audit may be required if income exceeds the basic exemption limit

"Gross receipts" means all fees from your profession: consultations, procedures, visiting fees from hospitals and any other professional income. Receipts from digital payments, cheques and bank transfers count as non-cash; this is what lets many clinics use the higher ₹75 lakh limit.

When presumptive tax is the better choice

  • Your real expenses are less than half your receipts. This is common for consultants who visit hospitals, doctors who rent a small chamber, and part-time practices.
  • You want simple compliance, with no detailed books.
  • Almost all your payments are digital, so the ₹75 lakh limit applies.

When full books are the better choice

  • You run a clinic with high rent, several staff, consumables and equipment, so genuine expenses exceed half your receipts.
  • You have bought expensive equipment, so depreciation is large.
  • Your receipts exceed ₹75 lakh, or ₹50 lakh with more cash.
  • You had a loss year, such as the first year of a new clinic, and want the loss recorded.

A worked example

Two doctors each receive ₹40 lakh in fees in tax year 2026-27, almost all by UPI and bank transfer.

Dr A is a consultant who visits two hospitals and rents a shared chamber. Real expenses, including chamber rent, travel, indemnity insurance and a part-time assistant, come to ₹8 lakh. Under the presumptive scheme, taxable professional income is ₹20 lakh. With full books, it would be ₹32 lakh. The presumptive scheme is clearly better.

Dr B runs a busy clinic with three staff, higher rent, consumables, a new ultrasound machine and depreciation. Real expenses come to ₹26 lakh. With full books, taxable income is ₹14 lakh. Under the presumptive scheme, it would be ₹20 lakh. Full books are better, even after paying an accountant.

The figures are for illustration only.

A simple test

  1. Add up your gross receipts for the year.
  2. Add up your genuine professional expenses, including depreciation on equipment.
  3. If expenses are well below half of receipts, presumptive tax is usually better.
  4. If expenses are close to or above half, compare both with your CA, including the cost of keeping books.

Records you still need under the presumptive scheme

Even without detailed books, keep:

  • A record of all receipts, ideally from your clinic software or bank statements.
  • Bank statements for all accounts.
  • TDS certificates from hospitals, and a check against Form 26AS or the Annual Information Statement.
  • Proof of advance tax paid.
  • Major asset purchases, because written-down values matter if you later move to full books.

Clean receipt records also help you show that cash receipts stayed within 5 percent if you rely on the higher limit. For a receipts register and the move from section 44ADA to section 58, see presumptive tax for doctors: from 44ADA to section 58.

Switching between the two

You can move between the schemes, but there are restrictions. Under the presumptive rules, if you opt out after using the scheme, the law may restrict your return to it for some years. Plan the choice with your CA rather than switching year to year.

Common mistakes

  • Forgetting hospital fees. Visiting fees from hospitals are part of gross receipts.
  • Assuming the ₹75 lakh limit applies without checking cash. Count cash carefully.
  • Ignoring TDS. Tax deducted by hospitals should match your return. See TDS on consultant fees.
  • Missing the 15 March advance tax date. Interest applies if you pay late. See advance tax for doctors.
  • Mixing personal and clinic money in one account. It makes any scheme harder to prove.

Where Bractis fits

Bractis records each bill and payment against the visit, with the payment mode, which gives you and your CA a clear record of gross receipts and of how much was cash. Payment status is attached to the visit. Plans start at ₹999 a month plus GST.

Frequently asked questions

Is section 44ADA still available after the new Income-tax Act?

Yes. The presumptive scheme for professionals continues under section 58 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, from 1 April 2026, with the same 50 percent rule and limits.

What is the 44ADA limit for doctors in 2026-27?

Gross receipts up to ₹50 lakh, or up to ₹75 lakh if cash receipts are no more than 5 percent of the total.

Can I claim clinic expenses under the presumptive scheme?

No. Expenses are treated as covered by the 50 percent that is not taxed. You cannot claim them separately.

Do I need an audit under the presumptive scheme?

Not if you declare at least 50 percent of receipts as income. Declaring less may require books and an audit.

Run this in your own clinic

Bractis is clinic management software built for Indian OPDs: appointments, patient records, prescriptions, billing and follow-up in one place. You can try it in your own clinic before you decide.

Sources and review

Written by the Bractis editorial team for doctors and clinic owners in India. Rules, fees and prices change: check the linked primary sources before acting, and ask your CA or lawyer about your own case.